Java 8 Optional. ¿De verdad hacía falta?

Java 8 Optional

¿De verdad hacía falta una API para tratar nulos?

Me surgen las siguientes dudas.

  • ¿Desde cuando tratar con valores nulos dentro de un programa se convirtió en un problema? 
  • ¿Es el temido NullPointerException realmente un problema del lenguage o del programa?
  • ¿Esta el Optional realmente simplificando la lógica del programa?
  • ¿Esta el Optional realmente ayudando a diseñar un programa más robusto?
  • ¿Esta el Optional realmente resolviendo el problema original?


 Hasta donde yo he podido llegar, no veo ninguna aportación ni a la programación ni al lenguaje el uso del Optional de Java 8. De hecho, lo que si he podido llegar a ver ha sido justamente lo contrario. Donde antes veía simples if ahora veo sobre-ingeniería, e incluyo utilización de APIs adicionales para tratar con los tales Optional. Después de ver esto, esto es tal y como yo lo veo:

  • La programación es un arte y por lo tanto el tratamiento de nulos también lo es.
  • El Optional es sencillamente más verbose que escribir directamente una sentencia if
  • Decorar o enmascarar un nulo no simplifica la lógica del programa
  • La robusteza de un programa no se gana añadiendo más capas
  • En Java ya existen mecanismos como el try-catch para tratar errores inesperados
  • El uso de lambdas no ahorra código y no justifica la utilización de tal API


 Para terminar, creo que no habrá ningún framework que vaya a solucionar lo que para mi son errores de programación, ni hacer un programa más robusto por arte de magia; con Optional o sin Optional, seguirán habiendo NullPointerException con total seguridad; de hecho la susodicha API los lanza. Sin embargo, si google y Java han diseñado tales APIs para tratar nulos, la pregunta que realmente que me queda es: 

  • ¿Qué me estoy perdiendo y donde están los ejemplos reales que justifiquen el diseño y la utilización de semejante API?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to build a replicated ehcache through firewall and not to die trying

It's assumed that:

You already have a java application and you have an ehcache instance running in your program with 1 cache configured to replicate.You want to connect 1 instance to another instance you have in a remote machineThe remote machine you are connecting to is located behind a firewall.You have been given access to only 1 port to make an ssh connection to the remote (firewalled) machine. Ehcache uses RMI to connect the remote instances. When the cache in host 1 tries to connect to cache in host 2, RMI opens a new server socket in host 1 to listen for incoming connections from the host 2.
The problem here is that these random ports are not accesible to remote hosts because the hosts are behind a firewall.

So to fix it, we need to configure ehcache to only use 2 ports. The "remoteObjectPort" does the magic. So we have this ehcache.xml configuration:
1 server port for the ehcache server to listen to other ehcache servers.1 server port for the ehcache cache to liste…
Read more

Android 3D Model Viewer Open Source

So finally I decided to publish my 3D model Viewer android app on the Google Play Market :)

This app is about drawing 3D objects in android using OpenGL ES 2.0; and its Open Source as my other projects, so people can either contribute, start a similar project based on that or just learn how to do it by looking at the source code.

Although there is already similar apps on the market and lots of 3D frameworks out there, neither of the published apps are Open Source.

So I wanted to learn how 3D works and I think the best way to understand how it works is by looking at how matrices transforms the objects in space and how pixels are drawn to the screen. Thats why this app does not use any third party framework.

So far the app serves as a model viewer, but I have some ideas of what can be done with the code; or as I prefer to think of it, mini-3D-framework.  So for example, I am thinking in creating my very first and simple mini-game and I want to do it in 3D as it is a matter I really like…
Read more

Google Drive FTP Adapter

Image
Google Drive FTP Adapter
This open source application lets you connect your FTP applications to your Google Drive files through the FTP protocol rather than using the Official's Google Drive client.
This custom google drive client was created because official's one can't be reinstalled in a new PC without having to redownload all your drive files again, from the cloud to your local PC.  So if you have hundred of Gigas and a regular ADSL it would take weeks to complete. Also, because the official client does not support FAT32 partitions and I used to have all my files in one of this partitions.
So this application basically starts a FTP server in your local machine emulating that it is hosting your google drive files, acting as a gateway. Once this setup is done, you can connect any FTP client to connect to your google drive files. I use it in conjunction with Beyond compare to compare my local files (stored anywhere in my hard drive) and compare them to ones I have in the…
Read more